Under Threat of Lawsuit, DEC Promises to Treat Lake as Wilderness

 

            Faced with a pending lawsuit from a regional green group, the state Department of Environmental Conservation is pledging to manage the man-made Lows Lake as if it were classified as wilderness – even though it is not. 

            Last month, three state agency designees on the Adirondack Park Agency Board of Commissioners reversed their previous positions and struck down a proposal that would have included the water and lakebed of Lows Lake in the wilderness classification of roughly 10,000 acres of recently acquired state land surrounding it.

            After the vote, Adirondack Mountain Club Executive Director Neil Woodworth told WNBZ that a lawsuit could follow the APA decision. 

            He said it is the agency’s duty to classify all recently acquired lands and that the State Land Master Plan allows for waters to be included in classification packages. 

            But although the measure to include the water failed, preceded by a media blitz by angered local officials opposed to the expansion of agency jurisdiction, DEC Commissioner Pete Grannis is making some promises to the mountain club. 

            “Effective immediately, the department will manage Lows Lake as a wilderness lake, subject only to existing riparian rights and the limited floatplane access recently provided for,” Grannis writes in a letter to Woodworth. “I am writing to reconfirm the department’s commitment to establishing a wilderness canoe route through Lows Lake as called for in the Adirondack Park State Land Master Plan.” 

            Several privately owned parcels on the lake have grandfathered riparian rights, and even motorboats will be allowed on the lake in some areas – both of which are inconsistent with the wilderness designation.

            The mountain club brought the Lows Lake battle to the forefront of recent discussion after suing DEC for allowing the continued use of floatplanes on the popular canoeing and fishing water body. 

            Several of its members had complained to DEC that the presence of the engine driven machines was ruining their wilderness experience. 

            Local governments fired back, claiming that trips to Lows Lake were vital to the survival of the two remaining floatplane operators in the park. 

            The current plan will eliminate floatplane access on January 1, 2012.

            -Jon Alexander, 12-9-09 

Return to News Headlines